The short answer
Usually, yes. The IRS says the employer stays responsible for depositing and paying federal employment taxes even when a payroll service handles them, so penalties and interest land on your account. The main exception is a certified professional employer organization, which is generally solely liable for taxes on wages it pays to worksite employees.
Key takeaways
- When an ordinary payroll service provider fails to deposit, the IRS holds the employer liable for the tax, penalties and interest.
- Owners and other responsible people can also be personally liable for the trust fund portion of unpaid payroll taxes.
- A certified professional employer organization (CPEO) is generally solely liable for employment taxes on wages it pays to worksite employees.
- Enrolling in EFTPS with your own PIN lets you check every federal deposit made under your EIN.
- The IRS advises employers not to change their address of record to the payroll provider's address.
You paid your payroll company every pay period. Then an IRS notice arrives saying deposits are missing. It's a gut punch, and the honest answer to the first question most owners ask is not the one they want: in most arrangements, the IRS still treats the business as the party that owes.
Who the IRS holds responsible
The IRS's guidance on outsourcing payroll is blunt. The employer is ultimately responsible for depositing and paying federal tax liabilities, even if it forwards the money to a third party to make the deposits. If the third party doesn't pay, the IRS may assess penalties and interest on the employer's account, and the employer is liable for all of it. The same page warns that the employer may also be held personally liable for certain unpaid federal taxes.
That last point is about trust fund taxes: the income tax and employee share of Social Security and Medicare withheld from paychecks. If those go unpaid, the IRS can assess the Trust Fund Recovery Penalty against the people responsible for paying them. A payroll company's failure doesn't automatically shield the owner from that.
The type of arrangement changes the answer
"Payroll company" covers several legally different setups. The IRS publishes a chart comparing them, and the liability row is the one that matters here:
- Payroll service provider (PSP). Prepares returns and makes deposits using your EIN. The employer, not the PSP, remains liable for timely filing and payment.
- Reporting agent. Authorized on Form 8655 to sign and e-file returns and deposit for you, still under your EIN. Again, the employer remains liable.
- Section 3504 agent. Appointed on Form 2678 and files aggregate returns under its own EIN. The employer and the agent are both liable.
- Certified professional employer organization (CPEO). Has a Form 8973 contract with you and files under its own EIN. Generally, the CPEO is solely liable for employment taxes on wages it pays to worksite employees. The CPEO and the customer may both be liable for wages paid to non-worksite employees.
So the first thing to establish is which of these you actually signed up for. A PEO that isn't IRS-certified doesn't get CPEO treatment. The IRS created the voluntary certification program after Congress required it in 2014, and only organizations the IRS has certified carry the CPEO label.
If your contract, the forms you signed and the returns filed all point to a CPEO relationship covering these employees, the liability picture is very different, and the IRS correspondence should reflect that once it's sorted out.
Find out what was and wasn't paid
You can't fix a gap you can't measure. Start here:
- Get into EFTPS with your own credentials. The IRS recommends that employers enroll in the Electronic Federal Tax Payment System with their own PIN and use it to verify payments regularly. Once enrolled, you can see about 16 months of payment history. Enrollment involves IRS validation and a PIN mailed to your address of record, so start now.
- Pull your account transcripts for each affected quarter to see what was filed and what posted.
- Compare against your payroll registers and the amounts you sent the provider. Those transfers are evidence of what you paid and when.
- Check whether returns were filed. Some failed providers stop filing as well as depositing, which adds failure-to-file penalties.
EFTPS also lets you make deposits yourself. If you're switching providers, you can use it to cover the current period so new liabilities don't pile on top of old ones.
Contact the IRS early
The IRS asks employers who think a bill or notice stems from a payroll provider problem to contact it as soon as possible. Call the number on the notice, write to the office that sent it, call the business line at 800-829-4933, or visit a local IRS office.
Keep the IRS mailing to you. The IRS strongly suggests employers don't change their address of record to the payroll provider's address, because that can keep notices from ever reaching the business. If your provider made that change, correct it.
When you call, have the notices, your registers and the proof of what you sent the provider. Penalty relief based on reasonable cause can be requested, and the IRS considers each request on its facts. Expect questions about what steps you took to monitor the provider.
Steps beyond the IRS
The IRS side is only part of it:
- State agencies. State withholding and unemployment taxes may be unpaid too. Check with each state where you have employees.
- Your payroll contract. Many agreements include indemnity or error-correction clauses, and some providers carry insurance or bonds.
- Fraud reports. The IRS notes there have been prosecutions of people and companies posing as payroll providers who stole funds meant for employment taxes. If money was diverted, reporting it to law enforcement may matter for any recovery.
- Your own records going forward. Each missed or late deposit is a red flag, in the IRS's words. Treat the first one as a reason to check everything.
Recovering money from a failed provider is a civil matter between you and that company. It doesn't change what the IRS shows on your account in the meantime, so work both tracks at once.
Paying what's owed
If the business can't cover the missed deposits in one payment, the options mirror any other payroll tax balance: short-term time to pay, a payment plan, or in harder cases a collection alternative. The Form 941 payroll tax guide covers how those balances are collected and why staying current on new deposits is a condition of nearly every arrangement.
When to bring in help
This is one of the situations where professional help often earns its cost:
- More than one quarter is missing, or returns weren't filed.
- The IRS is asking about trust fund liability or has sent an interview request to an owner or officer.
- You believe you had a CPEO relationship and the IRS is billing you anyway.
- State agencies are also involved.
If you'd like a tax relief professional to review the notices with you, get matched free.
Frequently asked questions
Can the IRS make me pay payroll taxes my payroll company stole?+
In most cases, yes. With an ordinary payroll service or reporting agent, the employer remains liable for unpaid deposits plus penalties and interest, even if the money was given to the provider. A certified PEO arrangement is the main exception.
How do I check if my payroll taxes were actually paid?+
Enroll your business in EFTPS with your own PIN and review the payment history, and request IRS account transcripts for each quarter. Compare both with your payroll records.
What is the difference between a PEO and a CPEO?+
A CPEO is a professional employer organization the IRS has certified. For wages it pays to worksite employees, a CPEO is generally solely liable for federal employment taxes. An uncertified PEO doesn't get that treatment.
Will the IRS remove penalties if my payroll provider failed?+
It may, if you show reasonable cause. The IRS reviews each request on its facts, including what you did to monitor deposits. Interest is reduced only to the extent penalties are.
General information, not legal or tax advice. Rules change and depend on your facts.