Search for help with IRS debt and you will find an industry that spends heavily on advertising and, in places, considerably less on the work. Some firms are excellent. Some collect a retainer and file very little. The difference is not visible from the outside, but it is visible in how a firm answers questions.
The nine questions
1. Will you review my IRS account transcripts before quoting anything?
The single most useful question. Transcripts show what the IRS has actually assessed, what payments were applied, whether a substitute return was filed, and where the collection clock stands. Anyone quoting a strategy or a figure without reading them is guessing.
2. What do you think I'll qualify for, and why?
A good answer references your income, expenses and assets, and is hedged. A bad answer is a confident number delivered in the first five minutes.
3. Who will actually handle my case?
In some firms the person who sells is not the person who works the file, and the working file may sit with someone unlicensed. Ask for the name and the credential.
4. What are the fees, in writing, and what do they cover?
Fees should be quoted in writing before any work starts, with the scope defined. Ask specifically whether additional years, appeals, or an audit are included or billed separately.
5. What happens if the IRS rejects the application?
Rejections happen even in well-prepared cases. What matters is whether the appeal or resubmission is covered, and whether the firm has a plan for it.
6. Are all my returns filed, and if not, do you handle that?
Almost nothing is available while returns are missing. If unfiled years exist, that work has to happen first, and you need to know whether it is in scope.
7. How will you communicate, and how quickly?
The most common complaint about tax relief firms is not the outcome. It is silence. Ask for a specific expectation and hold them to it.
8. Are you licensed to represent me before the IRS?
Attorneys, CPAs and enrolled agents may all represent taxpayers under Circular 230. Anyone else cannot. This is a yes-or-no question and the answer should be immediate.
9. What is the realistic worst case?
A firm willing to describe the downside is a firm that has thought about your case. One that has no worst case is describing a sales script.
Two answers that should end the conversation
- A specific settlement amount promised before anyone has reviewed your finances. The Offer in Compromise calculation depends entirely on numbers nobody has yet seen.
- Pressure to decide today, or a discount that expires. Tax problems are rarely so time-critical that an hour's thought is unaffordable — and the genuinely urgent deadlines are the reason to move, not an artificial discount.
Put all nine to any firm you consult, including the uncomfortable ones.
Frequently asked questions
Should I choose a local tax attorney?+
For federal tax debt, rarely a deciding factor — IRS matters are handled by correspondence and phone, and the office handling your file is unlikely to be in your town regardless. Local knowledge matters more where a state authority is involved, since state rules and practices differ substantially.
Are flat fees or hourly rates better?+
Flat fees give certainty and are common for defined work like an Offer in Compromise. Hourly can be fairer for unpredictable matters such as an audit. What matters more than the structure is that the scope is written down, so you know what triggers an additional charge.
What if I've already paid a firm that did nothing?+
It happens more than it should. Request your complete file and an accounting of work performed, then check your IRS transcripts to see what was actually filed — that record is usually the clearest evidence either way. Complaints can be raised with the state bar or licensing body, and separately with consumer protection authorities.
General information, not legal or tax advice. Rules change and depend on your facts.